The Foodies

Cooking And Gardening For Young Children.

The Foodies / Blog / Book And Other Product Reviews / Review of E-Numbers By Stefan Gates

Search:

Welcome to The Foodies Blog, a mix of real children's recipes, opinions, reviews and campaigns.

We've put all the blog posts into categories to make them easier to find. Please leave a comment on anything which interests you.

If you'd like to be told about future blog posts, please use the sign up box below.



Categories

Book And Other Product Reviews (8)Cooking (1)Eating (3)Family Recipe Testing (12)General and Intro (2)Growing (5)Interviews (4)News, Events & Campaigns (8)

Most Recent Entries

Peppermint CreamsSave With Jamie - Win A Free Copy Our ten favourite fun looking snack ideasEasy Berry Ice CreamA Bit Of A Rant On A Slight Segway

Subscribe to our blog

Get notified by email when
we add a new blog entry.

Enter Your Email:

 


04/07/2011 10:26:00

Win A Copy Of E-Numbers by Stefan Gates

"Warning - this book may make you feel happier about your lunch!"

There is an astonishing amount of myth and misunderstanding around E-numbers. They are universally billed as the bad guys of food, and yet they play a critical role in food safety. In this book and the accompanying TV series, Stefan Gates investigates the real truth about E-numbers.

If you fill your grocery cart based on what you have read in the Daily Mail or been told on the news, you'd have a hard job finding things to put in that don't scare you to death. Ok so maybe you might be able to slip a few vegetables in, as long as you can overlook that they might have been sprayed with something unpleasant or that they might have e-coli if you don't cook them til they steam.... And foods containing E-numbers are right there on the hit list.


This book in no way seeks to convince you to eat lots of processed junk. Quite the contrary, Stefan Gates (parents know him from CBBC's Gastronuts but you might also know him from the fascinating travel food show Cooking In The Danger Zone)is very much in favour of cooking real food which keeps us healthy. It's just that he also believes that food should be a source of pleasure and adventure and that the culture of fear around food does none of us any good. Hence his investigation into E-numbers to find out whether or not our fear of them has foundation.

I particularly liked this explanation for his project from the introduction to the book:
"I love food, but I hate bullshit. [...] By bullshit, I mean the cliches, mantras, cherry-picked research, unquestioned nutritional assumptions and half truths spread without a second thought by food writers, TV chefs, reporters and media nutritionists. The most damaging of these are the widely held beliefs that all E-numbers are bad for you, that preservatives are unnecessary and that it's a conspiracy of faceless food manufacturers, scientists and the government - rather than ourselves - who are to blame for bad nutrition and food poisoning. The food industry does indeed cause some crippling environmental, social and medical problems (more about these later), but blaming E-numbers for them is a lazy shortcut that skips over real issues of personal accountability for health."

Food substances are only given an E-number when the EU has tested them and deemed them safe for human consumption, for a specific purpose, and usually up to a specified maximum safe limit. A few of them are indeed what we imagine - artificially created chemicals, invented in a lab, which flavour, preserve or colour foods and may or may not be used to replace more wholesome or expensive ingredients or disguise the poor quality of food. However, others are completely naturally occurring substances which are present in home cooked food (like riboflavin E101 naturally present in wheat), or even in home grown raw foods (like Vitamin C E300 naturally present in many fruits and vegetables). Still another group are substances which are actually created by our own bodies (like human fat - glycerol E422 or hair which comprises 14%L-cysteine E920). Not only that, but the air we breathe is full of E-numbers (oxygen is E948 and nitrogen is E941 for example).

In this book, Stefan follows several ingredients back through the manufacturing chain to find out where they come from, eats a diet packed with E-numbers and tries to exceed the limits allowed by the EU to see if it affects his health. He also covers the intolerances and adverse reactions associated with that group of E-numbers which are often cited as the real bad guys of food, including the Southampton Six Colours, Aspartame and MSG . He charts how food safety has developed over the centuries and why regulations like the EU numbering scheme were necessary to save human life. His investigations take up the first third of the book (and were filmed for the BBC show of the same name), and go some way to pointing out the misunderstandings which easily arise when people are frightened by media rhetoric. A good example is Gillian McKeith's plea for us to avoid E162 Beetroot Red in her book "You Are What You Eat", followed by her advice four sentences later to instead use "red pigments obtained from beets". E162 Beetroot Red is a red pigment obtained from beets.

The remainder of the book is a really useful list of all 391 E-numbers, explaining what each one is, what it is used for and whether we should be scared of it. With a handy index at the back this makes the book in to a useful reference guide if you want to know how to read your labels more effectively.

Even as a fairly food-educated reader, I found a lot of the information in this book really enlightening. It certainly had the desired effect of providing full and frank information to enable me to make informed buying choices, but at the same time, giving me confidence that eating some foods with E-numbers isn't likely to kill me. Critically, Stefan points out that the presence of E-numbers in a food is not, by itself, a guide to the healthiness of its ingredients, but that some of the foods which we think of as "bad for us and full of E-numbers" are actually bad for us because of their other ingredients as much or more so than the E-numbers themselves. E-numbers are indeed sometimes used as a lazy shortcut by manufacturers to make cheap and nutritionally bankrupt foods more palatable. But those foods are just as likely to be bad for us because of their levels of salt, hydrogenated fats, caffeine, sugar, cattle growth hormones or other items, none of which carry an E-number. Some foods containing E numbers will be very wholesome, and many foods containing damaging ingredients may not include E-numbers at all, so reading the label has to be a more sophisticated process than just excluding Es.

Because I think this book is well worth reading, I have bought an additional copy to give away to a reader of this blog. If you would like a chance to win a free copy, simply add a comment about this blog piece, and on Monday 11th July I will put the names of commenters in to a hat (an actual hat as it happens, my son has a straw son hat from Spain!) and send one lucky person a copy through the post.

So what do you think about E-numbers? Do you try to avoid them? Do you know what any of the numbers are? What are your issues when trying to read labels on food?

Please add your comments before 1 pm on Wednesday 11th July.

This competition is now closed. Thanks to everyone who wrote a comment. The winner of the free book is... Janet Flett! Congratulations.


Comments

04/07/2011 16:02:00 by Clara Rix

I'd be interested to read this book. I find shopping a bit of a chore, trying to read the labels and work out what to buy. There are just so many things to take in to account and even with fresh food you're not sure where it's come from and what's happened to it.

04/07/2011 16:32:00 by Eszter Erdelyi

I am very interested in this book because the E numbers are supposedly so much better than the US numbers we have to put up with... please bring on the science!

05/07/2011 11:46:00 by Deb Goodyear

I have always tried to avoid foods which have more than two or three E-numbers on them, but someone pointed out that some packets just have the full name of the chemical on them instead, so it's hard to tell. Not sure now whether I should be focussing on something else. Would enjoy reading the book to find out!

05/07/2011 14:53:00 by Janet Flett

I'm so looking forward to reading this book whether won or bought . There is far too much contradictory and sensational advice and reporting out there. It will be great to get a balanced and considered view.

12/07/2011 10:11:00 by Kerrie Matthews

I saw the TV show that went with this book, a few months ago. Thought it was brilliant - you got to see him making red dye from squashing bugs and getting E numbers from vomit and liposuction. Really made me rethink a bit about the whole 'artificial' thing. Haven't read the book though and would love to.

12/07/2011 12:13:00 by Tristan Robinson

There are certain E-numbered food additives that I would avoid, such as artificial food colourings, flavourings, certain preservatives etc. I don't avoid E numbers completely though, many are natural foodstuffs in themselves and, being a scientist, I always remember that E-numbered foods (and the levels of them used) must be safe in order to be used at all - there are strict criteria for their usage. Incidentally I don't read newspapers routinely, so am not influenced by scaremongering stories from the printed press.

13/07/2011 10:02:00 by Dale Evans

I learned a few things already from this review. I am all in favour of common sense, and knowing the facts instead of jumping blindly on the bandwagon seems to be key here. Stefan Gates clearly know his onions (sorry, couldn't resist!)and I would love to read this book. Thanks for reminding me to check him out!

Subscribe to this Blog

 


You might also like…

Save With Jamie - Win A Free Copy

Save With Jamie - Win A Free Copy

04/07/2011 10:26:00

Save With Jamie - Can You? Win a free copy of the Save With Jamie Book and see if you can make any savings. On Monday, Jamie Oliver's TV series "Jamie's Money Saving Meals" finished its run of six programmes on Channel Four, and the accompanying book "Save With Jamie" is now out. The series aims to help us to "Shop Smart, Cook Clever and Waste Less". If you've watched any of the series, you'll have a rough idea of the approach Jami...

Our ten favourite fun looking snack ideas

Our ten favourite fun looking snack ideas

04/07/2011 10:26:00

Our 10 Favourite Fun Looking Kids' Snack Ideas. I've been spending a lot of time on Pinterest and other cool ideas sites lately and have found some absolute gems of ideas for fun looking snacks for children. Here are my ten favourite ones of the last few weeks. They are all reasonably healthy (some of them are for sharing) and none of them require a degree in cake decorating, architecture or landscape gardening to achieve. Try some out and tell me what you think. If yo...

Call To Action - SOS School Food

Call To Action - SOS School Food

04/07/2011 10:26:00

CALL TO ACTION - CAN YOU PLEASE SPEND 1-2 MINUTES TO HELP TO PROTECT SCHOOL FOOD? As you may know, Michael Gove asked the Dimblebys from Leon restaurant chain to draw up another school food plan. Whether you consider this a stalling tactic on his part or a valid process, we should still contribute. They can only use the information which is out there to format their plan, whether it is research evidence or us telling them our opinions. We can't complain about the outcome if we don't...

Garden Crafts For Children by Dawn Isaac

Garden Crafts For Children by Dawn Isaac

04/07/2011 10:26:00

Garden Crafts For Children by Dawn Isaac I hope you won't mind me mentioning Chr***mas when it's still only November, but I have a great recommendation for a stocking filler for a child in your life. I'm not on some kind of commission or something(!) I just genuinely think it is a lovely book. Garden Crafts For Children is a fab book by Dawn Isaac, who is a garden designer and writer of the lovely kids gardening blog Little Green Fingers....